In late February, the Tampa Bay Times reported a single-family sale on West Beach Park Drive. The Tampa Bay Times item said 4507 West Beach Park Drive sold on Feb. 5 for $4.23 million and listed the house at 2,219 square feet, four bedrooms and two bathrooms. That works out to $1,905 per square foot. The seller was Taralon Homes LLC, a custom builder.
Dropped into a comparison spreadsheet, that number would distort every Beach Park estimate built on it. The county's own record for the parcel describes a much larger house, and the gap between the two descriptions points to the most useful thing a buyer can learn about this neighborhood. In Beach Park, the year a house was built and whether it sits on the water set the price more than its size does.
What the county record shows for 4507
The Hillsborough County parcel record for the same address, folio 1138920000, tells a different story. It shows a recorded sale of $4,226,500 dated Feb. 3, 2026, on a 0.30-acre parcel. The county's year-built field reads 2025, and it lists 5,295 heated square feet with four bedrooms and five bathrooms.
At 5,295 square feet, the sale comes to about $798 per square foot. That's still a premium figure, and it's less than half the number in the headline. The county record and the sales summary describe the same parcel, the same sale and two very different houses. Only the county figures match a 2025 home sold by a builder.
Taralon Homes describes itself as a Greater Tampa Bay custom builder founded in 2011 by Mike Bartoletta and Scott Kirchner, and it calls itself a South Tampa builder. When a builder is the seller, check the county record before trusting the size an automated summary reports.
Four houses of the same size, sorted by age
The same Times item listed three nearby sales from 2025. When you pull the county parcel records for all four, they make an unusually clean comparison. Every house is between roughly 5,000 and 5,400 square feet, and all four sit within a few blocks of each other on West Beach Park Drive and West Dale Avenue.
| Address | County year built | Heated sq. ft. | Lot | Sale price | Sale date | Approx. $/sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4507 W Beach Park Dr | 2025 | 5,295 | 0.30 ac | $4,226,500 | Feb. 3, 2026 | $798 |
| 4647 W Beach Park Dr | 2004 | 5,369 | 0.37 ac | $3,500,000 | Feb. 18, 2025 | $652 |
| 4523 W Dale Ave | 2018 | 4,986 | 0.24 ac | $2,895,000 | Aug. 22, 2025 | $581 |
| 4517 W Dale Ave | 2005 | 5,252 | 0.39 ac | $2,850,000 | Apr. 4, 2025 | $543 |
The per-square-foot figures are our own division of each recorded sale price by the county's heated area.
The 2025 house sold for $726,500 more than the 2004 house down the street. It is 74 square feet smaller and sits on a lot about 0.07 acre smaller. Compared with the 2005 house on West Dale Avenue, the gap is $1,376,500, and that house has the largest lot of the four. Size and land don't explain those gaps. Age does.
The 2018 house on West Dale sold for a little more per square foot than the 2005 house next door but well below the 2004 house on West Beach Park Drive. The 2018 house also has the smallest lot in the group. Within a few years of construction, location on the block, lot shape and finish level reshuffle the order. Across a span of twenty years, the newest house still clearly leads. A buyer comparing a 2005 Beach Park home with a 2025 one is pricing two different products that happen to share a neighborhood name.
Water frontage is the other dividing line
Year built sorts the interior streets. Frontage on the water sets the ceiling. In its roundup of the region's most expensive 2025 sales, the Tampa Bay Times included two Beach Park homes.
39 W. Spanish Main St., built in 2017 with 5,274 square feet on a 0.34-acre waterfront lot, sold for $8.8 million. That house is nearly the same size as the four interior homes in the table, yet it sold for more than twice the price of the 2025 build on West Beach Park Drive. It comes to roughly $1,670 per square foot.
20 Sandpiper Road, completed in 2023 with 8,766 square feet on a 0.22-acre waterfront lot, sold for $8.6 million. That's about $980 per square foot. The house is far larger and newer than the Spanish Main home, on a smaller lot, and it sold for slightly less. Once a Beach Park parcel touches the water, size stops tracking price in any straight line.
The eighth entry on the same Times list is 334 Blanca Ave. on Davis Islands, where the house was torn down and the 0.54-acre lot with 133 feet of frontage on Hillsborough Bay sold for $8.7 million at land value. Davis Islands is a different neighborhood, and that sale put a South Tampa waterfront lot with no house on it in the same price range as the two finished Beach Park waterfront homes.
Where the next new houses come from
The price gap between original homes and new builds is what keeps Beach Park's builders active. Bravery Construction's South Tampa page, updated in October 2026, names Beach Park among the interior neighborhoods with larger lots and new homes on teardown lots. Crescent Homes lists Beach Park among its South Tampa custom-build neighborhoods. Brookshire Homes shows a custom home of more than 5,700 square feet with a pool and spa at 4502 Beach Park Drive.
A builder's estimate from 2023 put the remaining original homes at about 80. That count dates from 2023. Some of the originals are significant houses in their own right. In June 2024, Creative Loafing profiled 828 S Bayside Drive, a 1925 house with 248 feet of water frontage and 6,272 square feet, then listed at $8 million.
The pipeline is visible on the ground too. On South Gardenia Avenue, a new house is going up at No. 207 on a 100-by-138-foot double lot of 0.32 acre, with an asking price of $4.2 million and completion targeted for December 2026. That asking price sits right next to the $4.23 million recorded at 4507 W Beach Park Drive, which suggests builders are pricing to the most recent comparable new-construction sale in the interior streets.
Beach Park sits in its own tier of the county
For scale, the Florida Realtors report on Hillsborough County single-family homes for September 2026, released Oct. 16, shows a countywide median sale price of $419,450. That month the county had 4.0 months of supply, a median of 40 days to contract and 4,708 active listings, 3.6% fewer than in September 2025.
None of the Beach Park sales above came within $2.4 million of that median. Countywide supply and speed numbers describe a market of $400,000 homes, and they say little about how a 2005 house on West Dale Avenue will compete against a 2025 build a few doors away. At this price point, the useful comparables are recent sales on nearby blocks, sorted the way the table above sorts them.
Five checks before you trust a Beach Park comp
- Match the seller type. If a builder sold the home, confirm its size and year built in the county record, even if a sales summary lists a small, older house.
- Pull the county parcel record. The Hillsborough County parcel data shows year built, heated area and lot acreage. Compare those fields with the listing's description before you calculate anything per square foot.
- Group by decade before size. In the table above, the price spread between a 2005 house and a 2025 house of the same size was more than $1.3 million.
- Separate water from interior. A waterfront sale like 39 W. Spanish Main St. belongs in a different comparison set from homes on West Beach Park Drive or West Dale Avenue, even though they share a neighborhood.
- Price the original homes against two outcomes. An original house on a large interior lot competes both with other original homes and with what a builder could sell on that lot. The $4.2 million asking price on South Gardenia Avenue and the $4.23 million recorded on West Beach Park Drive mark the second outcome.
For more on the neighborhood itself, our Beach Park neighborhood page covers the streets between Westshore and Old Tampa Bay. Owners thinking about a sale can read our notes on selling a luxury home in Beach Park.
If you own an original Beach Park home or a newer build, the sales that set your number are probably the ones on your own blocks, sorted by year built and by water. Austin Marks Group can sort those sales with you, address by address. Start with a free home valuation, and we'll show you which Beach Park sales your home actually competes with.